Dispatch, 2026-11-12, SHC Team, Data control
California's new law limits what lawyers can put into AI tools
Filed 2026-11-12 · SHC Team
On Sept. 30, California's governor signed SB 574, setting rules for attorneys and arbitrators who use generative artificial intelligence (AI), tools that write text or make images on request. From Jan. 1, 2027, a California lawyer may not put confidential or other nonpublic information into an AI system unless access is restricted to the lawyer and people they authorize.
What happened
The bill, by Senator Umberg, passed 75 to 0 in the Assembly and 39 to 0 in the Senate, and was filed as Chapter 858 of the 2026 statutes. It adds a new section to the State Bar Act, the law that regulates California attorneys. A lawyer may not hand the practice of law over to generative AI. A lawyer who uses it for legal work must take reasonable steps to check what it produces, including every case and statute it cites, and fix anything wrong or invented. They must also tell the court when AI was used on documents filed there.
The law never uses the phrase "public AI." It bars entering confidential, personal identifying and other nonpublic information into an AI system where access to what the lawyer types in "is not restricted to the attorney and persons authorized by the attorney under obligations to protect the confidentiality of the information." Personal identifying information is defined to include dates of birth, Social Security numbers, account numbers, and financial, medical or psychiatric information.
A court filing may not contain any citation the responsible attorney has not personally verified, including citations supplied by AI, and courts may sanction violations of that section. Arbitrators may not hand any part of their decisions to an AI tool. The attorney section does not list a separate penalty. The bill has no urgency clause, so under the state constitution it takes effect Jan. 1, 2027.
What changes for you
The statute is California's, but its question reaches any firm that uses AI. When someone pastes client facts into an AI tool, who else can get to that text? The test is who can access what goes in. The law does not sort tools into free or paid, or public or private. The answer sits in each vendor's terms, settings and contract.
This is not legal advice. Whether the law applies to you, and whether a given tool meets it, is a question for your state bar or ethics counsel.
What you can do
- List every AI tool in use at the firm, including free personal accounts and AI features built into software you already use.
- Ask each vendor in writing who can access what you type in, how long it is kept, and whether it is used to train a model. Keep the answers with your firm's records.
- Write a short firm rule on what may go into each tool, and name who checks every citation before anything is filed.
- Ask your bar or ethics counsel before Jan. 1 how SB 574, or your own state's rules, apply to your practice.
- If you want AI that isn't sent to an outside AI company, our law firm page explains how the private AI we run handles client work. Whether any setup meets your rules is for you and your counsel to decide.
Sources
- California Legislative Information, "Bill Text - SB-574 Attorneys, arbitrators, judicial officers, and alternative resolution providers." (chaptered version, Chapter 858, Statutes of 2026), 2026-09-30
- California Legislative Information, "Bill History - SB-574 Attorneys, arbitrators, judicial officers, and alternative resolution providers.", 2026-09-30
- California Legislative Information, "California Constitution, Article IV, Section 8", 2016-11-08